Skip to main content
Menu

Animal welfare   |   Ethical business   |   Organics

Sirloin, rib-eye or retired?

Last year, 346,000 dairy cows over the age of 30 months were slaughtered in Great Britain (according to industry body AHDB), most of which goes to the commodity beef market as ‘cull cows’ for processing into mince, low-grade ready meals or perhaps pet food.

But one organic farm’s nose-to-tail philosophy is finding ways to end the ‘waste’ of dairy cattle carcasses once they have stopped milking.

Ben White rears a mixed herd of 1,000 dairy and beef cattle at Coombe Farm Organic in Somerset. He first retired one of his dairy cows three years ago to mark the Soil Association’s Organic September campaign, and became the first and only organic farmer to be selling retired dairy beef in the UK.

Since then, the numbers have gradually increased and today he has between 35 and 50 retired dairy cows: “We’d like to get to a point where we have a really efficient dairy and at the end of their milking days, all of our ladies go on to pasture for six months and then make really fantastic meat. It’s about building a market and making sure that these organic animals are celebrated.”

According to White, retired dairy beef “personifies organic”: “This meat shows off the best of this food system, from high animal welfare to diversification for the farmer and minimal waste that matches with our nose-to-tail philosophy – we’re doing right by the animal,” he says.

Cow
Redundant dairy cows would usually be sent for slaughter into low-grade meat. Image Coombe Farm Organic. 

“But most other cows are literally walking out in their working boots to a lorry, having had a desperate life of being milked more often, being fed crap, put to the bull more often, being given preventative medicine their entire life and then literally carted off to the slaughter house – that’s what we don’t like [about conventional farming],” says White.

After six months grazing on pasture alongside other female cows that are either pregnant and out of the milking chain, or ‘drying off’ and waiting to be seen by the bull, these retired cows are slaughtered and sold as retired dairy beef. Having been fattened up on a rich diet of organic grass with herbs, peas and barley, the meat is, according to White, beautifully marbled, full of flavour and rich in nutrients such as Omega-3s.

Because the animals are older, some thicker cuts can also be a little tougher: “There is a bite to it, you do have to chew it but we were given molars and incisors for a reason,” explains White, who suggests cooking retired dairy beef more slowly, perhaps searing in a pan then cooking in the oven.

Every retired dairy beef steak has a story, as he explains: “The product’s batch number links to the cow’s passport number and right back to conception on this same farm. That’s a staggering amount of traceability and there aren’t many farms that control the whole supply chain from beginning to end.”

“Organic retired dairy beef sums up everything that’s good about what we do because these cows have had a lifetime of that approach to farming. Our cows have been fed on organic grass, milked less often, had fewer calves, and at the end of their milking life they get to be in the field for six months before going to a small, independent abattoir just seven miles away – then they come back to our own butchery and meat goes direct to our consumer. That’s quite a journey,” says White, who believes that as a nation we need to eat better quality, higher welfare meat, but less of it in order to farm in a more environmentally-sustainable manner.

Ben White
Ben White with farm manager Ryan Sloman-Brown at Coombe Farm Organic.

“Being organic is what makes our retired dairy beef special. To market a product that has come out of a conventional dairy, as opposed to an organic dairy, just exacerbates a problem, rather than providing a solution,” explains White. “But equally, it makes no sense to send organic dairy cows off to a large-scale abattoir once they are finished being milked because they’re not then realised for the product they are.”

Elsewhere, retired dairy beef is a delicacy that’s being embraced in the US, particularly in New York State and California, while in northern Spain, farmers traditionally retire ex-dairy cattle onto plentiful pasture amongst cider orchards for up to four years to produce 'Basque beef'.

When White first tasted Basque beef at a food festival in London, he says he’d never seen fat content like it before: “I’d never seen people go so crazy for grass-fed animal fat but it’s in vogue because more people are recognising its nutritional value and content.”

Retired cows
Meat from retired dairy cows is prized in Spain and the US. Image Coombe Farm Organic. 

Within the industry, there isn’t yet an official standard for what counts as retired dairy beef, so White defines it as an animal that has been retired for between three and six months.

Depending on when their yield drops off, or if they fail to conceive, they might be retired at four years old or 12. At Coombe Farm Organic, where the herd is predominantly Fresian, it’s typically between six and nine years old.

In fact, White crosses dairy with beef cows so there isn’t any pedigree beef stock at the farm. “That allows us to do both beef and dairy efficiently alongside each other,” he says. “If you’re prepared to eat milk, yogurt and cheese, you should be prepared to try retired dairy beef and encourage your farmer to finish that animal so you’re getting the best product at the end of it.”

And while demand for retired dairy beef might never surpass that for Aberdeen Angus, White firmly believes that it deserves a bigger slice of the (steak) pie.    

    Comments

    AliceFavre

    9 Months 2 Weeks

    YES. This will be my plan when we hopefully start the calf at foot dairy... my old conventional farmer also put me on to this about 3 years ago. He was a terrible farmer though.

    0 Reply

    Antsarecool

    8 Months 2 Weeks

    Is this the same Coombe Farm in Somerset found in breach of Soil Association and RSPCA welfare standards in 2018, subsequently dropped by Waitrose but somehow allowed to keep their SA certification? One of your suppliers?? The undercover footage is really harrowing. So now instead of selling the retired dairy "ladies" as cheap meat, he lets them graze for 6 months and then sells them as more expensive meat.. Sorry, instinctively not loving this.

    1 Reply

    view replies

    Comments Editor

    8 Months

    Hi Antsarecool, I hope I can help with the points you raised. Wicked Leeks is an editorially independent magazine published by Riverford, covering news, views and stories from sustainable food and ethical business. With lots of debate and raising challenging questions too, we are separate to other Riverford publications such as the newsletter that arrives in the veg boxes.

    Riverford have long term partnerships with their own Soil Association certified small scale organic farmers supplying beef and dairy, with very high standards of herd welfare. They have not used Coombe Farm as a supplier, and the story was just covered by Wicked Leeks.

    That said, we have been reassured by Ben White, the general manager of Coombe Farm, that their organic certification was upheld following this particular situation and after unannounced audits from certifiers including the RSPCA, the Soil Association and Red Tractor. If you have more questions please do feel free to email wickedleeks@riverford.co.uk with your contact details and Ben will gladly have a chat about anything you want to raise.

    0 Reply

    Wicked Leeks is out now

    Cover star, Jyoti Fernandes, tells of the small producers standing up for their rights, while elsewhere we explore climate-friendly eating and how to eat seasonal in spring.

    Read now

    Choose food that hasn't flown.

    Riverford organic veg boxes are delivered directly to your door. Choose your box now.

    Go to Riverford

    The net zero counter narrative

    Read our coverage of the new trend for net zero and see beyond the headlines.

    Read more

    Grow Your Own

    Our monthly gardening advice column offers timely advice for your organic patch, whether you're an expert grower or just starting out.

    Explore
    LETTERBOXRiverford-organic-veg-boxes.png

    Boom in organic unmatched by farming

    Sales of organic boomed during 2020 as the pandemic boosted interest in food quality but growth will be met by imports as UK farmers hold back.

    Read more
     

    Join the Wicked Leeks community

    Sign up for the newsletter and receive the five latest stories, once a week. Wicked Leeks magazine is published by organic veg box company Riverford.

    Spread the word

    The twin crises of climate change and biodiversity losses will be the defining stories of our future, but it is not too late to change direction. 

    Here at Wicked Leeks, our mission is to help inform and inspire positive change. Our journalism is free to all because of this, but we want to reach as many people as possible who share our desire for a better world. We know our readers are some of the biggest advocates of sustainable living, and you can help us grow this movement by sharing this article widely, with your friends and on social media. Now is the time to act.