Back in 2022, anti-factory farming campaigner and author, Philip Lymbery, raised the alarm about one of the most pressing environmental issues of our age: the state of the world’s soil. In his seminal book, Sixty Harvests Left, Lymbery highlighted the ever-starker links between industrial farming and the decline of soil quality, amongst a catalogue of other negative impacts associated with large-scale livestock production.
Just a few years before, the UK’s then Environment Secretary, Michael Gove, had warned that Britain was just 30 or 40 years away from what he called “the fundamental eradication of soil fertility” in parts of the country. He blamed intensive agriculture, stating that “we have encouraged a type of farming which has damaged the earth” and argued that “no country can withstand the loss of its soil and fertility.”
Soil, as both Lymbery and Gove realised, and indeed many scientists had pointed out previously, is fundamentally critical for life on earth and serves a multitude of vital functions that may not be immediately obvious. It acts as a water filter, provides nutrients for the crops that feed us and is home to millions, if not billions, of organisms that make up the world’s diverse ecosystem.
It also helps mitigate the ongoing climate emergency by acting as a carbon sink, storing carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases that would otherwise be released into the atmosphere. Unknown to many, soil captures more CO2 than the planet’s forests, and is second only to the oceans in terms of carbon storage.
But as a natural resource, it’s remarkably undervalued and under-protected, in comparison to our rainforests and oceans. Now, leading experts are calling for a global soil treaty to be urgently phased in to protect this most valuable natural asset that is, according to some estimates, also worth trillions of dollars.
Academics from the University of Sydney argue that the failure to protect soil stems, in part at least, from a fundamental misunderstanding of the resource itself, stating that the world “treats soils as separate entities when they function as an interconnected planetary system.”
In a sobering new paper published this week in the European Journal of Soil Science, Dr Quentin Styc and Professor Alex McBratney assert that recognising soil as a single global system “is essential” to securing its future.
“We have spent centuries classifying soils according to their different properties, uses and locations. But in doing so, we’ve lost sight of the bigger picture,” said Styc, who teaches at the University’s School of Life and Environmental Sciences and Sydney Institute of Agriculture. “Soil doesn’t stop functioning at national borders. What happens to soil in one country can have profound consequences for ecosystems, economies and food security on the other side of the world.
“We have international treaties to protect the ocean and atmosphere. Yet the soil beneath our feet, which is fundamental to human civilisation, remains without equivalent protection.”
We cannot solve a planetary challenge with a patchwork of disconnected policies Dr Quentin Styc, soil scientist and Postdoctoral Research Associate at The University of Sydney
In their paper, the duo point to a powerful example of apparent global interconnectedness, highlighting that each year, more than 27 million tonnes of dust originating in Africa’s Sahara Desert crosses the Atlantic Ocean, delivering roughly 22,000 tonnes of phosphorus to the mighty Amazon rainforest. The academics say that this “natural fertilisation” replaces nutrients lost through flooding, helping sustain one of the world’s most biodiverse ecosystems.
They also highlight some of the less beneficial connections between soils, citing erosion, contamination from chemical pesticides and microplastics, that can all, according to the study’s authors, spread across borders and contribute towards both food insecurity and climate change itself.
“These connections demonstrate why soil security cannot be achieved by countries acting independently,” Styc said. “We need to think about soil in the singular, just as we increasingly talk about one ocean rather than separate oceans. It’s a change in language that reflects a much bigger change in how we understand our responsibility for the planet.”
The study hints at the stakes involved, citing some estimates that as much as 40% of the world’s land is classified as degraded, which threatens significant economic output. Yet despite this, the study also finds that meaningful soil protection remains scattered across various international agreements dealing with climate change, biodiversity and desertification.
As an example, the authors point to the United Nations Convention to Combat Desertification which they maintain focuses on drylands, while other international agreements address functions of soil, such as carbon storage or biodiversity. None, the academics say, provide a comprehensive, binding international protection for soil as a planetary system.
Governance and protection of the world’s seas is seen as offering a potential model for change for soil, with Styc and McBratney highlighting that, following decades of negotiations, an international agreement to protect marine biodiversity in areas beyond specific jurisdictions came into force earlier this year. “When environmental damage crosses borders, international cooperation needs to match the scale of the problem. We cannot solve a planetary challenge with a patchwork of disconnected policies,” Styc said.
The future of soil security
There is some movement towards achieving better recognition, and protection, for global soils. Last year, the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) approved a resolution that advocated for a fully binding international legal instrument on soil security, and other recent proposals have outlined a clear “pathway” towards a “Global Convention to Secure Soil”, with a target date of 2032 for its adoption. This initiative, if it happens, would establish a coordinated international framework while allowing countries to develop soil security strategies suited to their own environmental and economic circumstances.
“Soil underpins our food systems, biodiversity, water security, and climate resilience, yet it remains largely invisible in international environmental governance,” said the University of Sydney’s McBratney.
Closer to home, away from the global arena, the urgency of addressing the soil problem was underscored by a recent report that found that more than 60% of the EU’s agricultural soils were degraded due to intensive agriculture, with similar damage affecting around 40% of British soils.
This situation, the study found, is changing the land’s water cycle and exacerbating impacts of the climate crisis in an effective vicious circle. Degraded soils, lacking their natural structure, are incapable or less capable of holding water in any quantity, meaning that when it rains the water tends to run off, worsening flooding, the research said. At the other extreme, in times of drought, when healthy soils would act as a sponge, poor soils have little resilience.
The report’s authors have called for soil restoration to be made a priority of climate change programmes, and for changes in farming policies and subsidies in order to recognise and reward it.
Philip Lymbery’s own investigations for Sixty Harvests Left included a notable anecdote: “I […] see soils on the move; I see maize, a common animal-feed crop, planted in tramlines down local hillsides, encouraging soil to run towards the river. And when soil goes into the river, so too do chemical fertilisers and pesticides, causing pollution.
After heavy rain, the local roads can get choked with soil. Things got so bad that the residents of one hamlet nearby woke up one morning to find that part of a field had slid into their garden, potatoes and all.”
One very localised example of a very global problem.
The AGtivist is an investigative journalist specialising in food and agriculture issues who’s been covering this beat for 20+ years. The AGtivist column at Wicked Leeks shines a light on the key issues around intensive farming, Big Ag, Big Food, food safety, and the environmental impacts of intensive agribusiness.










0 Comments